The Academy of Saint Dorothy encourages learning, strong sportsmanship, and teamwork through team sports. We are a member of the Catholic Youth Organization and the Staten Island Soccer League.We offer the following team sports:
| Basketball | (Kindergarten to Grade 8) |
| Baseball | (Kindergarten to Grade 8) |
| Softball | (Kindergarten to Grade 8) |
| Soccer | (Kindergarten to Grade 8) |
| Track | (Kindergarten to Grade 8) |